Marham
SurgeriesHealth HubForumJoin as Doctor

Book Video Consultation

  • Stay Home
  • No Waiting in lines
  • Audio/Video Call
  • PMDC Verified Doctors
View Online DoctorsView Doctors

Breast Surgeon (oncologist) advice required

Answered by 4 verified doctorsCancer Specialist / OncologistAsked 7 Jul 2025
Asking for:
Mother
Patient:
Female, 72 years old
Location:
Lahore

My mother has been diagnosed with breast Cancer, we have consulted oncoplastic Surgeon in Lahore and planned Lumpectomy on 21st July. We are confused about whether we opt for a mastectomy as I have read that it is possible that a lumpectomy surgery can be required again. Moreover, radiation will also be essential after a lumpectomy. please look into attached reports of ultrasound, mammography and biopsy and guide whether lumpectomy is okay and repeated surgeries and radiation can be avoided after lumpectomy? which one has less side effects and preferred treatment? -Lumpectomy with radiation -Mescotomy Please look into attached reports and give suggestions, we will be highly obliged, Jazzak Allah

Attachment for: Breast Surgeon (oncologist) advice required
Attachment for: Breast Surgeon (oncologist) advice required
Attachment for: Breast Surgeon (oncologist) advice required
Attachment for: Breast Surgeon (oncologist) advice required

4 answers

Dr. Saeed Ur Rehman

Dr. Saeed Ur Rehman

MBBS,FCPS, MRCPUK, MRCPI, SCE, Saudi Fellowship Medical Oncology, Medicine
Cancer Specialist / OncologistKarachi4.9(41 reviews)

both are viable options. both have their pros and cons. normally younger perfer lumpectomy due to cosmetic issue. Older patients some time not bother it. it patients discretion and choice. If you want to avoid radiotherapy in case indicated after lumpectomy, then go for mastectomy. choice would be yours. I hope my reply makes sense and help you out for decisions. Note: If you are confused, there is no harm for second opinion from Surgeons, they give you better inside of procedure

a year ago

Patient

a year ago

Jazzak Allah

Dr. Muhammad Afham Shahid

Dr. Muhammad Afham Shahid

MBBS, FCPS (Medical Oncologist), MRCP.SCE Medical Oncology (UK)
Cancer Specialist / OncologistLahore4.9(12 reviews)

Assalamualikum-wa-Rehmatullah-e-wa-Barakatuhu It is an invasive disease and there is no mention of axilla at all. I would personally recommend mastectomy arm at this age, and yes it preferably include axillary staging. This because, it might help skip adjuvant XRT. But in case you're so confused, try communicating with Oncologist in your access and try Breast surgeon vs Surgical Oncologists to add to your decision, especially if your current team did not mention the axilla. Duas.

a year ago

Patient

a year ago

Jazzak Allah Dr sb, yes we have consulted oncologist Surgeon and he has planned lumpectomy along with intraoperative identification of sentinel lymph node on 21st July. he also told that there is no need of radiation in the light of latest clinical trails CALGB nine three four three and prime 2 etc we have also consulted clinical oncologist, he just added that radiation might be needed after surgery but it depends on the after surgery biopsy report. at the age of 72 lumpectomy with radiation has low consequences or mescotomy has low consequences? Please reply in detail, May Allah Kareem bless you with healthy long life, Jazzak Allah

Dr. Muhammad Afham Shahid

Doctora year ago

Dear, in general lumpectomy carries more risk of cancer coming back. So, it is consolidated with XRT. <br>I would like clinical oncologist to supervise this in more detail if I were in your footsteps. Prime 2 says both groups had equal OS at the expense of more recurrences in people who skipped XRT. Moreover, go to clinical oncologist to ask what in your case is a contraindication to XRT. Is there any? Please keep in mind you don't know the outcome. But being too optimistic that XRT won't be needed at all, is a relative overstatement. Please be humble and get reviewed from oncologist that your diagnostic workup is complete and meets the optimal criteria. Allah ap k liyay aasani farmaye. Ameen.

Patient

a year ago

Jazzak Allah Dr Sb

Dr. Reena Kumari Sunil

Dr. Reena Kumari Sunil

MBBS , FCPS ( Medical Oncology)
Cancer Specialist / OncologistKarachi4.9(37 reviews)

Lumpectomy versus mastectomy result of both are equal. but with lumpectomy as u r already aware that post op radiation is mandatory. Now a days their is deescalation of previous surgical method every field is growing and with surgical techniques many women are cured with lumpectomies

a year ago

Patient

a year ago

Thanks Ma'am for your such a kind and detailed reply, we have consulted breast oncoplastic Surgeon in Lahore, he was saying that latest studies/trails like CALGB 9343 & PRIME II shows that radiation can be omitted in females over 70 years age. please guide are we on the right path?

Patient

a year ago

If we compare the consequences, whether lumpectomy with radiation or a Mastectomy is better?

Dr. M Sanaullah Qureshi

Dr. M Sanaullah Qureshi

MBBS, RMP , Diploma In Urology & Sexology
General PhysicianKhanewal4.9(29 reviews)

detailed history needed for better outcome Book appointment online or call at 042-32591427, <a target="_blank" href="https://www.marham.pk/online-consultation/general-physician/khanewal/dr-m-sanaullah-qureshi-042-32591427">https://www.marham.pk/online-consultation/general-physician/khanewal/dr-m-sanaullah-qureshi-042-32591427</a> book for as low as Rs 0 for today ur issue would be resolved IA

a year ago

Need a proper diagnosis?

Forum answers are general guidance and cannot replace an examination. For a diagnosis, book a consultation with a cancer specialist / oncologist — in person or by video.

More cancer specialist / oncologist questions

Basal Cell Carcinoma

It's been on my head for more than 2 months now. It's the biggest one. Also have 1 other in small size. What is it exactly & where to check it properly

Asking for: For selfPatient: Male, 338 years oldLocation: Lahore

1 doctor answerCancer Specialist / Oncologist4 days ago
How staging is done for cervical cancer?

My mother has been diagnosed with endometrioid adenocarcinoma of uterine cervix. Her MRI, CT, and Histopathology reports points towards stage IIA2. How will an oncologist stage her disease? And is there any other treatment option in Pakistan except chemo-radiation therapy?

Asking for: For motherPatient: Female, 48 years oldLocation: Gujranwala

4 doctor answersCancer Specialist / Oncologist17 days ago
Liver cancer

> Assalamu Alaikum Dr. > Patient: Hussain Mohammad, File no: 104780, Age 72Y > CT Abdomen Triphasic (30/09/2026) done after ablation on 01-09-2026. > > Report says: Old ablated lesions in seg VIII/IVA and seg V are stable with no tumoral enhancement (post ablation cavity). > But newly seen multipl

Asking for: For fatherPatient: Male, 75 years oldLocation: Al Farwaniyah

Awaiting an answerCancer Specialist / Oncologist20 days ago
Cancer problem

My Father has prostate gland cancer problem

Asking for: For selfPatient: Male, 81 years oldLocation: Kasur

3 doctor answersCancer Specialist / Oncologista month ago
See all cancer specialist / oncologist questions